Call For A Free Quote!

Residential and Commercial Roofing Contractor in Southern Wisconsin and Surrounding Areas.

Can You Replace Just a Few Pieces of Siding

Living in Janesville, WI, means dealing with tough Wisconsin weather—blizzards, heavy rain, and even the occasional hailstorm that can batter your home’s exterior. If you’ve noticed a few damaged pieces of siding on your house, you might be wondering, “Can you replace just a few pieces of siding, or do I need a full replacement?”

At Rooster Roofing, we get this question a lot from homeowners in Janesville, Beloit, Edgerton, and surrounding areas like Madison and Lake Geneva. 

The good news? In most cases, you can replace just a few pieces of siding, and we’re here to explain how it works in simple terms.

Whether you live near the Rock River, close to the Janesville Mall, or in a cozy neighborhood in Milton, keeping your home’s siding in good shape is key to protecting your house and boosting its curb appeal. Let’s dive into everything you need to know about replacing a small section of siding, including the process, costs, and why Rooster Roofing is your go-to siding contractor in Janesville, WI (53545, 53546, and beyond!).

Can you replace just a few pieces of siding
Can you replace just a few pieces of siding

Why Would You Need to Replace Just a Few Pieces of Siding?

Siding is like the skin of your home—it protects the walls from water damage, wind, and other elements. But sometimes, a small section of siding gets damaged. Here are some common reasons homeowners in Janesville and nearby cities like Evansville and Brodhead need to replace just a few pieces:

  • Storm Damage: Hail or strong winds, common in areas like Delavan or Monroe, can crack or dent vinyl siding or aluminum siding.
  • Accidents: Maybe a stray baseball from a game at Riverside Park hit your house, or your dog scratched up a piece of siding near the back door.
  • Water Damage: Leaky gutters (we install those too!) or poor drainage near your home in Madison can cause water to seep behind siding, damaging one or two boards.
  • Fading or Wear: Over time, sun exposure near landmarks like the Rotary Botanical Gardens can fade a single board or section, making it stand out.

Replacing just a few pieces is often a smart, budget-friendly option compared to a full siding replacement. It saves you money while keeping your home’s structural integrity and aesthetic appeal intact.

Can You Really Replace Just a Few Pieces?

Yes, in most cases, you can! At Rooster Roofing, we’ve helped homeowners across Janesville, Beloit (53511), and Lake Geneva fix small sections of siding without tearing off the entire wall. Here’s why it’s possible:

  • Vinyl Siding: Vinyl is one of the most common siding materials in Janesville homes. It’s installed in panels, so replacing a single board or small section is usually straightforward.
  • Aluminum Siding: Older homes near downtown Janesville often have aluminum siding. Damaged pieces can be removed and replaced with matching panels.
  • Fiber Cement Siding: This durable material, popular in newer homes in Edgerton or Milton, can also be repaired in small amounts without a full replacement.
  • Wood Siding: Though less common, wood siding on historic homes near the Janesville Country Club can be replaced piece by piece, though it may need extra care like sanding or a basecoat of primer.

The key is matching the new piece to your existing siding in terms of color, size, and type. Our team at Rooster Roofing knows how to source materials that blend seamlessly with your home’s exterior.

The Process of Replacing a Few Pieces of Siding

Replacing a few pieces of siding is a job best left to professionals, but it’s helpful to understand how it works. Here’s a step-by-step look at what we do when we visit homes in Janesville, Madison (53703), or Evansville:

  1. Inspection: We start by checking the damaged area. For example, if you live near Palmer Park and a storm cracked a few vinyl siding panels, we’ll inspect for water damage or issues with the underlying wall.
  2. Remove Damaged Pieces: Using tools like a pry bar, utility knife, or screwdriver, we carefully remove the damaged siding without harming nearby panels. This is tricky, so DIY attempts can sometimes cause more harm than good.
  3. Match the Material: We find a new piece of siding that matches your home’s existing material, color, and style. Whether it’s vinyl, aluminum, or fiber cement, we make sure it blends in.
  4. Install the New Piece: The new siding is secured with nails or screws, and we use caulk or sealant to ensure it’s waterproof. This is especially important in Wisconsin, where rain and snow can sneak behind loose siding.
  5. Final Touches: We check the area for a smooth finish, making sure the new piece doesn’t stand out. If needed, we apply a basecoat or touch-up paint for wood siding.

The whole process is quick—often done in a day—and leaves your home looking great again. For homes in Brodhead or Delavan, where weather can be harsh, we also check for related issues like damaged gutters or flashing to prevent future problems.

How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Few Pieces of Siding in Janesville?

The cost of replacing a few pieces of siding depends on several factors, but it’s almost always cheaper than a full siding replacement. Here’s what affects the price for homeowners in Janesville, WI, and nearby areas like Monroe or Milton:

  • Material Type: Vinyl siding is typically the most affordable, costing $2–$5 per square foot for materials and labor. Aluminum or fiber cement siding may cost a bit more, around $4–$8 per square foot.
  • Damage Extent: If only one or two panels need replacing, the labor costs are lower. For example, fixing a small section near your windows might cost $100–$300, depending on the material.
  • Location: If your home is in a hard-to-reach spot, like a steep lot near Lake Geneva, labor costs might be slightly higher.
  • Additional Repairs: If water damage or structural issues are found behind the siding, we may need to add insulation or waterproofing, which can increase costs.

At Rooster Roofing, we offer free inspections and estimates for homes in Janesville (53545, 53546), Beloit, and surrounding cities like Evansville and Madison. This helps you know exactly what to expect without any surprises.

Benefits of Replacing Just a Few Pieces

Choosing to replace a small section of siding has some big advantages for homeowners in Janesville and nearby areas:

  • Saves Money: It’s a fraction of the cost of a full siding replacement, making it a great option for budget-conscious families.
  • Quick Fix: Most repairs take just a few hours, so your home in Milton or Brodhead is back to normal fast.
  • Boosts Curb Appeal: A new piece of siding can make your home look fresh, whether it’s near the Janesville Ice Arena or in a quiet Delavan neighborhood.
  • Prevents Bigger Problems: Fixing damaged siding stops water damage, which can harm your home’s walls or insulation and lead to costly repairs.

Why Choose Rooster Roofing for Siding Repairs in Janesville?

At Rooster Roofing, we’re more than just roofing experts—we’re your local home improvement pros in Janesville, WI, and surrounding areas like Edgerton, Beloit, and Lake Geneva. Here’s why homeowners trust us:

  • Local Knowledge: We know Janesville’s neighborhoods, from the historic homes near the Rock County Courthouse to newer builds in Milton. We understand how Wisconsin weather affects siding and roofs.
  • Quality Materials: We use durable, weather-resistant siding materials like vinyl, aluminum, and fiber cement to ensure long-term durability.
  • Friendly Service: Our team explains everything in plain English, so you know exactly what we’re doing to your home.
  • Wide Service Area: We serve Janesville (53545, 53546), Beloit (53511), Madison, Evansville, Brodhead, Monroe, Delavan, Lake Geneva, and more.

Whether you’re dealing with a cracked piece of vinyl siding near the Janesville Mall or faded wood siding in a historic Edgerton home, we’ve got you covered.

Tips to Maintain Your Siding in Janesville

To keep your siding looking great and avoid frequent repairs, try these simple tips:

  • Clean Regularly: Rinse your siding with a garden hose to remove dirt, especially after storms in areas like Monroe or Madison.
  • Check for Damage: After a big storm, walk around your home (maybe with your dog!) and look for cracks or loose panels.
  • Fix Gutters: Clogged gutters can cause water damage to siding. We offer gutter installation and repair to keep water flowing properly.
  • Trim Trees: Branches rubbing against siding near places like Rotary Botanical Gardens can cause scratches or dents.

Get Your Free Siding Inspection Today!

If you’re in Janesville, WI, or nearby cities like Beloit, Edgerton, or Lake Geneva and wondering, “Can you replace just a few pieces of siding?” the answer is yes—and Rooster Roofing is here to help. Our team of home experts will inspect your siding, explain your options, and get the job done quickly and affordably.

📞 Call us at (608) 631-0004 or visit our website for a free estimate. Whether you’re near the Rock River, Palmer Park, or out in Evansville, we’re your trusted siding and roofing contractor. Let’s keep your home looking great and protected from Wisconsin’s weather!

Share on social media

Get your free quote